Discover hidden gem restaurants in New Jersey offering fantastic food without the fancy facade.

A restaurant doesn't need to look fancy to offer fantastic food. In fact, some of the best restaurants in New Jersey are easy to pass by. From historic diners to local Italian spots, these hidden gems are beloved by locals and reviewers alike. There are so many hidden gems throughout the state, but here are a few favorites with rave reviews.

1. Belmont Tavern – A Classic Italian Gem in Belleville, New Jersey

This local Italian restaurant is famous for its Chicken Savoy. It may just be a simple brick building, but the food is anything but basic. This classic Italian spot has been serving the community for decades. Try the Chicken Savoy or pasta dishes that locals rave about at 12 Bloomfield Ave., Belleville.

2. Grab a Hearty Bite at Seagraves Steak & Submarine in Salem

You won't find a sign on this small shop, but you will find some of the best subs in New Jersey. Their cheesesteak gives Philly a run for its money. Hidden in plain sight with no sign, Seagraves offers sandwiches so good they rival Philly’s famous cheesesteaks. Don’t miss their daily specials. You can visit this restaurant at 1 S Tilbury Rd., Salem.

3. Taste History at White Manna, Hackensack’s Legendary Burger Joint

This tiny shop has just a few seats, but it offers greasy burgers made to order. The sliders are addictive and affordable. They serve made-to-order sliders with fresh ingredients. Are you a burger lover? Please feel free to visit and experience it for yourself. You can find this spot at 358 River St., Hackensack. Be sure to pass by Hackensack River County Park for scenic views and walking trails.

4. White House Sub Shop Serves Iconic Hoagies in Atlantic City

This historic eatery offers mouthwatering subs and quirky memorabilia like a towel Frank Sinatra once used. When visiting with family, this spot is family-friendly, but note that parking and accessibility are limited. Their menu is simple and appealing, and the interior is casual and welcoming. Also, just a heads up, it can get busy, so it's best to visit earlier. Here is their address – 2301 Arctic Ave., Atlantic City.

5. Savor Authentic Caribbean Flavors at Bahama Breeze in Cherry Hill, NJ

This authentic Caribbean eatery offers a flavorful taste of the islands. They serve Caribbean-inspired cuisine in a tropical ambiance, offering a varied menu. Here you can try seafood, jerk dishes, or rum-infused cocktails. This restaurant is located at 2000 Route 38, Ste 1170, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002. They offer ample parking, and it is very popular. So, be sure to call ahead to confirm the wait time, especially during peak hours. For wheelchair accessibility, be sure to call earlier to confirm the restaurant's specific setup.

6. Lumberton’s Beloved Little Shop of Pizza

Little Shop of Horrors fans will love Little Shop of Pizza. They offer great deals, such as 99-cent cheese slices, and have a wide variety of items beyond just pie. Here are some details about operating hours - from Tuesday to Thursday, they are open from 10:30 am to 9:00 pm. On Friday and Saturday, they are open from 9:00 to 10:10 pm, while on Sundays, you can visit from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm. Delivery and pickup options are also available. You can visit them at 723 B Main Street, Lumberton.

7. Rutt’s Hut in Clifton Is a Must-Visit for Hot Dog Lovers

New Jersey hot dogs are in a league of their own, but this unassuming spot always comes out on top. A dining landmark, they are famous for their deep-fried rippers, featured on the Food Network, Travel Channel, and more. While parking options are available, you may actually need to arrive earlier, if you don't mind. This spot provides wheelchair accessibility. You can check them out at 417 River Road, Clifton.

8. Enjoy Timeless Steaks and Charm at Sammy’s Cider Mill in Mendham

This unique restaurant, once a speakeasy, serves food in a distinctly different way. You order your food at the counter when you walk in, then head down to the basement bar to wait. Definitely try the lobster. While reservations are not accepted at Sammy’s Cider Mill and Steakhouse, you can grab your dinner from 5:30 p.m. Wednesday through Sunday. You can find this restaurant on 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24).

9. Hidden Gem in Newton: Delicious American Fare at The Farmer’s Daughter

Head to this eatery with "no curb appeal" for its delicious American fare. They have a varied menu with something for everyone. You can easily access this restaurant at 161-165 Spring St, Newton, NJ 07860, and there is street parking in front of the store. When you visit, be sure to try craisins, bacon crumbles, house dressing, or toasted almonds. While here, you can visit Kittatinny Valley State Park for beautiful views and hiking trails.

10. This Jersey City Gem Serves Timeless Italian Comfort Food

This cozy Italian eatery is a community staple, serving delicious dishes like the shrimp-stuffed crab over pasta in clam sauce. It is a perfect spot for a casual dinner, with a cozy and homey atmosphere. You can find this restaurant at Laico's, 67 Terhune Ave., Jersey City, and it offers both in-restaurant dining and delivery options.